All states › Indiana › New Castle

Schools in New Castle, IN

Safety scores and transparency grades from federal incident data · 2021-22 collection

10SCHOOLS
3WITH TRUSTED DATA
$171,868TYPICAL HOME VALUE
83%OF CITIES COST MORE
Why no city ranking? Only 3 of 10 schools here have trustworthy data — we rank a city only when at least 5 do, so one school's numbers can't masquerade as a citywide pattern. Each school below still has its own full report.

Typical home value: $171,868 (Zillow ZHVI, 2026-06-30) — cheaper than 83% of ZHVI-matched cities. Comparing safety against price? See the Affordable & Safe guide.

All schools, safest first

SCHOOLDISTRICTGRADESSTUDENTSSAFETY SCOREGRADE
Blue River Valley Jr-Sr High SchBlue River Valley Schools07–1235477A
New Castle High SchoolNew Castle Community School Corp08–1287658A
New Castle Middle SchoolNew Castle Community School Corp06–0844612A
Blue River Valley Elementary SchBlue River Valley SchoolsPK–06340— insufficient dataD
Eastwood Elementary SchoolNew Castle Community School CorpPK–06279— insufficient dataD
James Whitcomb Riley Elem SchoolNew Castle Community School CorpKG–06255— insufficient dataC
Parker Elementary SchoolNew Castle Community School CorpKG–06327— insufficient dataD
Sunnyside Elementary SchoolNew Castle Community School CorpKG–05106— insufficient dataC
Westwood Elementary SchoolNew Castle Community School CorpKG–06266— insufficient dataC
Wilbur Wright Elementary SchoolNew Castle Community School CorpKG–06316— insufficient dataD