All states › New York › Bay Shore

Schools in Bay Shore, NY

Safety scores and transparency grades from federal incident data · 2021-22 collection

12SCHOOLS
2WITH TRUSTED DATA
$663,767TYPICAL HOME VALUE
9%OF CITIES COST MORE
Why no city ranking? Only 2 of 12 schools here have trustworthy data — we rank a city only when at least 5 do, so one school's numbers can't masquerade as a citywide pattern. Each school below still has its own full report.

Typical home value: $663,767 (Zillow ZHVI, 2026-06-30) — cheaper than 9% of ZHVI-matched cities. Comparing safety against price? See the Affordable & Safe guide.

All schools, safest first

SCHOOLDISTRICTGRADESSTUDENTSSAFETY SCOREGRADE
HEMLOCK ELEMENTARY SCHOOLBRENTWOOD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICTKG–0560892A
SOUTHWEST ELEMENTARY SCHOOLBRENTWOOD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICTKG–0596964A
BAY SHORE MIDDLE SCHOOLBAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT06–081,329— insufficient dataE
BAY SHORE SENIOR HIGH SCHOOLBAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT09–121,919— insufficient dataE
BROOK AVENUE ELEMENTARY SCHOOLBAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICTKG–02371— insufficient dataC
FIFTH AVENUE SCHOOLBAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICTKG–02388— insufficient dataC
GARDINER MANOR SCHOOLBAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT03–05637— insufficient dataC
MARY G CLARKSON SCHOOLBAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICTKG–02438— insufficient dataC
OAK PARK ELEMENTARY SCHOOLBRENTWOOD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICTKG–05722— insufficient dataC
SOUTH COUNTRY SCHOOLBAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT03–05487— insufficient dataC
WEST MIDDLE SCHOOLBRENTWOOD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT06–08860— insufficient dataE
WOODHULL SCHOOLFIRE ISLAND UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICTPK–0636— insufficient dataC