Schools in West Islip, NY

Safety scores and transparency grades from federal incident data · 2021-22 collection

7SCHOOLS

3WITH TRUSTED DATA

$760,065TYPICAL HOME VALUE

7%OF CITIES COST MORE

Why no city ranking? Only 3 of 7 schools here have trustworthy data — we rank a city only when at least 5 do, so one school's numbers can't masquerade as a citywide pattern. Each school below still has its own full report.

Typical home value: $760,065 (Zillow ZHVI, 2026-06-30) — cheaper than 7% of ZHVI-matched cities. Comparing safety against price? See the Affordable & Safe guide.

All schools, safest first

SCHOOL	DISTRICT	GRADES	STUDENTS	SAFETY SCORE	GRADE
MANETUCK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL	WEST ISLIP UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT	PK–05	500	95	A
BEACH STREET MIDDLE SCHOOL	WEST ISLIP UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT	06–08	432	67	A
UDALL ROAD MIDDLE SCHOOL	WEST ISLIP UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT	06–08	461	28	A
BAYVIEW ELEMENTARY SCHOOL	WEST ISLIP UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT	PK–05	393	— insufficient data	C
OQUENOCK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL	WEST ISLIP UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT	PK–05	411	— insufficient data	C
PAUL J BELLEW ELEMENTARY SCHOOL	WEST ISLIP UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT	PK–05	454	— insufficient data	C
WEST ISLIP SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL	WEST ISLIP UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT	09–12	1,294	— insufficient data	E