| East Orange STEM Academy High School | 06–12 | 569 | 95 | A |
| Ecole Toussaint Louverture | PK–05 | 267 | 92 | A |
| Dionne Warwick Institute | PK–05 | 343 | 74 | A |
| John L. Costley Middle School | 06–08 | 363 | 71 | A |
| Cicely L. Tyson Community Elementary School | PK–05 | 447 | 22 | A |
| Johnnie L. Cochran Jr. Academy | KG–05 | 146 | 10 | A |
| Althea Gibson Academy | PK–KG | 138 | — insufficient data | C |
| Benjamin Banneker Academy | PK–07 | 482 | — insufficient data | D |
| Cicely L. Tyson Community Middle/High School | 06–12 | 764 | — insufficient data | D |
| East Orange Campus High School | 09–12 | 1,471 | — insufficient data | E |
| Edward T. Bowser Sr. School of Excellence | PK–05 | 576 | — insufficient data | C |
| Gordon Parks Academy | PK–02 | 206 | — insufficient data | C |
| J. Garfield Jackson Sr. Academy | PK–05 | 240 | — insufficient data | C |
| Langston Hughes Elementary School | PK–05 | 428 | — insufficient data | C |
| Mildred Barry Garvin Elementary | 03–05 | 282 | — insufficient data | C |
| Patrick F. Healy Middle School | 06–08 | 369 | — insufficient data | D |
| Shelia Y. Oliver Academy | PK–07 | 344 | — insufficient data | D |
| Sojourner Truth Middle School | 06–08 | 308 | — insufficient data | D |
| Wahlstrom Early Childhood Academy | PK–KG | 38 | — insufficient data | C |
| Whitney E. Houston Academy | PK–08 | 388 | — insufficient data | D |